Laminate vs Vinyl Floors – Which Flooring Is Best for Your Home?

When planning a home renovation, one of the biggest decisions you’ll face is choosing the right flooring. In the debate of laminate vs vinyl floors, two of the most popular options in South Africa are laminate floors or vinyl flooring. At first glance, they may look similar, but each has unique strengths and drawbacks. Understanding the differences will help you make an informed choice that matches your lifestyle, design goals, and budget.

In this guide, we’ll compare laminate vs vinyl floors in detail, from cost and durability to water resistance and style. By the end, you’ll know which flooring is right for your home. For product options, see our full laminate flooring collection and vinyl flooring range.

What Are Laminate Floors?

Laminate floors are made from a high-density fibreboard (HDF) core with a photographic layer that mimics real wood, stone, or tile. A tough wear layer on top protects against scratches, stains, and fading. Laminate offers an affordable way to achieve a natural look without the high cost of hardwood.

What Is Vinyl Flooring?

Vinyl flooring, especially luxury vinyl tile (LVT) and stone plastic composite (SPC), is made from synthetic materials with a strong wear layer. It’s designed to be fully waterproof, making it suitable for moisture-prone areas like bathrooms and kitchens. Vinyl also comes in realistic wood and stone patterns, giving homeowners plenty of design freedom.

Cost: Which Flooring Fits Your Budget?

Price is a major factor for South African homeowners comparing laminate vs vinyl floors.

• Laminate floors usually start around R199 per m² and go up depending on thickness, design, and brand.
• Vinyl floors can cost more, especially premium SPC or LVT options, which often start around R350 per m².

Installation costs also vary. Laminate is quick to install thanks to its click-lock system, while vinyl may require subfloor preparation. For an accurate estimate, use our laminate flooring price guide.

Durability: Scratch vs Water Resistance

Both floors are durable, but in different ways.

• Laminate floors: Highly scratch-resistant, making them perfect for households with pets or kids. However, they are not fully waterproof and can swell if exposed to standing water.
• Vinyl floors: 100% waterproof, ideal for kitchens, bathrooms, and basements. However, they can be dented by heavy furniture if not protected.

If water resistance is your top priority, vinyl is the clear winner. If you need scratch protection, laminate is often the better choice.

Comfort and Sound

Comfort underfoot is another key difference.

• Laminate can feel firm, though underlay improves comfort and reduces noise. With the right laminate flooring underlay, sound absorption and warmth improve dramatically.
• Vinyl is softer and quieter, offering a cushioned feel that makes it a great choice for bedrooms and living rooms.

Aesthetics and Style Options

Both laminate and vinyl flooring are designed to mimic natural materials.

• Laminate flooring uses high-resolution photographic layers, giving it a crisp and realistic wood or stone look.
• Vinyl flooring has improved in recent years with embossed textures that look and feel like real wood.

Both options offer a wide range of colours, finishes, and plank sizes. If style is your priority, you’ll find excellent choices in both categories. Explore our vinyl flooring range and laminate collections to compare designs.

Installation: DIY or Professional?

• Laminate floors: Easy to install with a click-lock floating system. DIYers often choose laminate because it doesn’t require glue or nails.
• Vinyl floors: Some types (SPC and LVT click-lock) are also DIY-friendly, while glue-down vinyl requires professional help.

If you want a quick and simple installation, laminate is slightly easier. But for full waterproof protection, vinyl SPC click-lock is a strong competitor.

Maintenance and Cleaning

Both flooring types are low-maintenance.

• Laminate should be cleaned with a slightly damp mop or microfiber cloth. Excess water must be avoided.
• Vinyl is easier to maintain since it is fully waterproof. Spills can be wiped without worry, making it perfect for busy family homes.

For maintenance tips, see our guide on vinyl tile flooring.

Environmental Impact

Eco-conscious buyers often ask about sustainability.

• Laminate floors are made from wood by-products, making them more eco-friendly. Many brands also offer recyclable options.
• Vinyl is synthetic and less eco-friendly. However, newer SPC products are designed with safer materials and improved recyclability.

If sustainability matters most, laminate has a slight advantage.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

When comparing laminate vs vinyl floors, avoid these common mistakes:

1. Ignoring room function – don’t put laminate in a bathroom where water is constant.
2. Skipping underlay – laminate flooring requires proper underlay for sound and comfort.
3. Not protecting furniture – heavy items can dent vinyl without pads.
4. Overlooking long-term costs – vinyl may last longer in wet areas, while laminate performs better in dry, high-traffic spaces.

Laminate vs Vinyl Floors: Which Should You Choose?

The choice comes down to your needs:

• Choose laminate floors if you want affordability, scratch resistance, and realistic wood looks for dry areas.
• Choose vinyl floors if you need waterproof performance, comfort, and quiet flooring for busy family homes.

For inspiration, compare our laminate floors and vinyl flooring to see which style fits your home best.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheaper: laminate or vinyl?
Laminate is usually cheaper per square metre, though vinyl may save money long-term in wet areas.

Which lasts longer?
Both can last 15–25 years. Vinyl performs better in moisture-prone rooms, while laminate excels in dry spaces.

Which looks more like real wood?
Both look realistic, but laminate’s photographic layer often has sharper detail. Vinyl’s embossed textures provide a natural feel.

Which is better for kitchens and bathrooms?
Vinyl flooring wins here thanks to its 100% waterproof construction.

Which is better for living rooms and bedrooms?
Laminate floors are durable, affordable, and stylish, making them a strong choice for these areas.

Conclusion

Both laminate and vinyl flooring are excellent choices for South African homes. Your decision depends on your lifestyle, budget, and the rooms you’re upgrading. For kitchens, bathrooms, and basements, vinyl is often the safer bet. For bedrooms, lounges, and offices, laminate delivers unbeatable value and a stunning finish.

Explore our full Laminate Floors website to compare products, request a quote, and find the best solution for your home.